Is Your Child Out of Control?

At one time or another, all parents feel like their child is acting out of control. But eventually this feeling passes as the event passes. But for some parents, an out-of-control child is not a fleeting phenomenon but a 24/7 reality. These children constantly push the limits and seem to care very little (if at all) about the consequences. They fight every transition. They can turn every grocery run into a forty-minute hostage standoff.

Is that kid yours? Are you using cutesy names like “threenager” and “fournado” to describe your kid’s behavior? Maybe someone else referred to him as strong-willed, deeply feeling, spirited, or explosive. You’re not alone. Your kid is likely showing you he needs something different from what he’s getting right now. If you’re worried, talk with your pediatrician.

What the Research Calls These Kids

Researchers have names too. In the 1950s, child psychiatrists Alexander Thomas and Stella Chess started tracking children's temperament from infancy. About 10% of the kids they followed fit a "difficult" profile: irregular sleep and eating, pulling back from anything new, slow to adapt, tantrums when frustrated (AJP review). Pediatrician W. Thomas Boyce calls the most reactive kids "orchid children." They feel their environment more intensely, the good and the bad (UCSF).

What It Feels Like for Dads

The research spends a lot of time on the kid. Here’s the part about you. If you're raising one of these kids, some of this will sound familiar:

  • Tired in a way sleep doesn't fix. The vigilance is constant. You're always scanning for the next trigger. Some days the job feels like management.

  • Watched. Public meltdowns draw stares and whispers. And this starts to feel like a grade on your parenting.

  • Guilty. After the storm passes you replay the day looking for what you did wrong. You’re racked with guilt and you can’t seem to get a handle on it.

  • Angry. Then ashamed of the anger. School drop-off starts to feel like the best time of the day. You love this kid, and you also want to scream into a pillow by 7 a.m.

  • Alone. Other dads' kids seem easier. Every playdate feels like a risk.

  • Strained at home. Parents of fussy, difficult children report lower marital satisfaction and more trouble balancing work and family (Lumen Learning, citing Hyde et al., 2004).

And it compounds. In a Toronto cohort of 148 kids, high parenting stress during infancy roughly doubled the odds of mental health problems at age 3, even after adjusting for the child's temperament (BMC Public Health, 2020). Your stress is part of the system. That's hard to hear. It's also the most hopeful finding here, because it's the part you can change.

What Helps a Strong-Willed Child

Make Every Day Predictable

Routines and sameness help highly sensitive kids. The same bedtime sequence. The same goodbye at drop-off. The same heads-up before every transition. Boring is good. For what’s typical at each stage, see Parenting Challenges by Age.

Preview and Practice

Preview new things, then repeat them. Slow-to-warm-up kids tend to engage once they can re-experience a new situation over time without pressure (AJP review). Drive past the new school. Visit the new pool twice before lessons start.

Set Boundaries and Stick to Them

Do you know why many kids test their parents and their boundaries? Because they have a strong need to feel safe and secure. When they test you and you hold steady, your child learns that you’re in charge and they don’t have to be. When you make a rule and set boundaries, be sure to always follow through with consequences.

Be Very Clear

Long explanations get lost. Use fewer words. Give clear directions. Stop asking them to do things and giving them options. Although it might have worked at one time, none of it is helpful for these kids.

Give Them 15 Minutes of Child-Led Play

Shoot for every day. Make it the last thing you do at night. Let them run the show, and pile on the praise for the things they’re doing. Repeat the things they’re saying. Join in and describe what they’re doing. Don’t be afraid to copy them! Most importantly - let them know how much you’re enjoying your time with them. Do it every day. Small daily doses add up.

Ways to Help Yourself

  1. Say it out loud. To your partner. To a friend. "This is really hard" is a complete sentence. Saying it lowers the pressure to perform.

  2. Treat your stress as part of the plan. Sleep, exercise, and time away count as interventions for the whole family.

  3. Tag-team the hard moments. Pick the two worst transitions of the day. Split them. Trade weekly so nobody carries bedtime forever.

  4. Retire the scoreboard. Your kid's timeline is your kid's timeline. Comparing them to the neighbor's dandelion only adds weight.

  5. Find other dads in it. Isolation makes everything heavier. A room of guys who get it makes it lighter. Get support from other dads who understand what you’re going through. If it’s wearing you down, therapy for dads in Durham is a place to sort it out.

Learn more about therapy for dads, or book a free phone consultation.

Sources

https://www.verywellfamily.com/help-my-kids-are-out-of-control-1094959

Cedarpath Counseling sees dads in person at 1200 Broad St. in Durham, NC, and by telehealth anywhere in North Carolina.

Previous
Previous

The Half-Present Dad: Phones, Distraction, and What Kids Notice

Next
Next

What to Do When You Feel Like You Can't Do Anything